Skip to content
Merito
In this section

On Balance Beneficial to Waive the Job Offer and Labor Certification

EB-2 NIWEB-2 NIW

6 min read

In short

This is the third part of the test in Matter of Dhanasar for a national interest waiver. It asks whether, weighing all the factors together, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the job offer and the labor certification that EB-2 petitions normally require. The petitioner must show this by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning more likely than not.

Also known as: Dhanasar prong three · Beneficial to waive the job offer · Beneficial to waive labor certification

Where it applies

  • The term belongs to the EB-2 NIW category. The statute, 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(2)(B), lets the government waive the requirement that a person's services be sought by a U.S. employer when it deems a waiver to be in the national interest. The Policy Manual states that this waiver applies only to the second preference (EB-2) classification, and that a waiver of the job offer also includes a waiver of the permanent labor certification requirement.
  • Matter of Dhanasar sets out three elements. The first two concern the proposed endeavor (substantial merit and national importance) and whether the person is well positioned to advance it. The third is the balancing question described here. Dhanasar says the framework applies after eligibility for EB-2 classification has been established, so this prong is not a substitute for showing the underlying classification.

Why it matters

Dhanasar states that USCIS may grant a national interest waiver if the petitioner shows all three elements. A record that addresses the endeavor and the person but says little about why the waiver itself is beneficial leaves one of the three elements without direct support.

The prong also explains what the waiver gives up. Dhanasar describes the ordinary route: an employer obtains a labor certification from the Department of Labor, which reflects a determination about available workers and effects on wages and working conditions. Congress, in creating the waiver, recognized that in certain cases the benefits of that process can be outweighed by other factors also deemed to be in the national interest. A record that explains why this is such a case speaks to the prong directly.

Dhanasar also says that when all three elements are satisfied, USCIS may approve the waiver as a matter of discretion. The wording is permissive, not mandatory.

How USCIS evaluates it

A balance, not a checklist

Dhanasar describes the inquiry as a weighing. On one side, Congress sought to protect the domestic labor supply through job offers and labor certifications. On the other, Congress created the waiver because those benefits can sometimes be outweighed by other national-interest factors. Dhanasar says Congress entrusted the Secretary to balance these interests within individual adjudications, so the reading is made case by case.

Factors named in Dhanasar

Dhanasar lists considerations an adjudicator may weigh, including whether the United States would still benefit from the person's contributions even assuming other qualified U.S. workers are available, and whether the national interest in those contributions is sufficiently urgent to warrant forgoing the labor certification process. The decision stresses that the factors considered must, taken together, indicate that on balance a waiver would be beneficial.

No comparison with an unidentified U.S. worker

Dhanasar replaced the older third prong of the earlier New York State Department of Transportation test. That older prong could be read to call for evidence of harm to the national interest or comparisons with unidentified U.S. workers, and Dhanasar notes this effectively asked for evidence tied to the labor market test the waiver is meant to forgo. Under the current framework the question is whether a waiver is beneficial on balance.

Expertise alone is not enough

A footnote in Dhanasar says a petitioner must go beyond showing expertise in a field. Exceptional ability is defined in the regulation as expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered, yet the decision says individuals of exceptional ability are generally subject to the job offer requirement and cannot qualify for a waiver just by showing that degree of expertise.

How the decision applied the prong

In Dhanasar itself, the petitioner held three graduate degrees in fields tied to the endeavor and had considerable experience in a specialized field. The decision pointed to the research's implications for national security and competitiveness, and to repeated funding by agencies including NASA and the DOD. It concluded that his contributions were of such value that they would benefit the United States even assuming other qualified U.S. workers are available.

A practical example

The following is an invented illustration. A materials engineer proposes to develop a testing method for battery components and claims a waiver. The file includes a description of the endeavor, funding records from a public agency that supported earlier work, and a letter from an agency program officer explaining why the method matters to a national program. A separate section of the cover letter then addresses the third element directly: it explains that the benefit of the work would remain even if other qualified workers exist, and it points to the documents that show the work's urgency. Each statement is tied to an exhibit, so a reader can check the claim against a source.

A common misconception

One mistaken reading is that showing high expertise, or that no U.S. worker could do the job, is what this prong requires. Dhanasar says instead that expertise alone does not qualify a person for a waiver, and that the question is whether, on balance, waiving the job offer and labor certification would benefit the United States, even assuming other qualified U.S. workers are available.

Common problems

  • The prong is left unaddressed

    Some records argue the endeavor and the person's skills at length and then stop. Because the third element is a separate requirement in Dhanasar, a record that never explains why a waiver is beneficial leaves that element without an argument or exhibit an officer can point to.

  • Arguments built on the old comparison

    A submission that centers on showing the person is better than an available U.S. worker follows the older NYSDOT framing, which Dhanasar set aside. Such an argument does not speak to the balancing question that the current prong asks.

  • Claims of urgency or benefit with no source

    A statement that the work is urgent or valuable, with no document behind it, gives an officer nothing to check. Funding records, agency statements or other third-party material show where the claim comes from.

  • Expertise presented as the whole answer

    Describing credentials and experience, without linking them to a benefit the United States would receive, runs into the point in Dhanasar that expertise alone does not support a waiver.

How to document it

  • A short section addressing the third element by name

    Stating the question in the words of Dhanasar and answering it with exhibit references lets a reader see how the record speaks to the prong.

  • Government or agency funding and support records

    Dhanasar treated repeated agency funding of the petitioner's research as an indication that the work was found promising and useful, so such records show an outside body's interest.

  • Letters from agency officials or independent experts

    A letter that explains the specific benefit of the work, and who benefits, gives context beyond the petitioner's own account.

  • Evidence of urgency

    Dated material, such as program documents or policy statements, can show why the contribution is needed without waiting for the labor certification process.

  • Evidence that the benefit holds even if other workers exist

    Documents describing what the person's particular work adds help address the question Dhanasar poses about other qualified U.S. workers.

  • Proof of EB-2 eligibility, kept separate

    Degree or exceptional-ability evidence shows the underlying classification, which Dhanasar treats as established before the waiver analysis.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Build your evidence checklist

Last reviewed October 22, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.