Skip to content
Merito
In this section

Final merits determination

EB-1AHow USCIS decides

5 min read

In short

The final merits determination is the second step of an EB-1A review. After the criteria are counted, the officer weighs the whole record to decide whether the person has sustained national or international acclaim and belongs to the small group at the very top of the field. Meeting three criteria is necessary for this step, but it does not decide it.

Also known as: totality review · step two of the Kazarian analysis

Where it applies

  • EB-1A (extraordinary ability) petitions on Form I-140 and their appeals to the AAO. USCIS guidance describes it as part of the extraordinary ability standard, and decisions in our corpus frequently open their analysis with it once the criteria have been addressed.
  • A similar overall judgment exists for the O-1A visa, where the standard is a level of expertise placing the person among the small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field, but the O-1A has its own regulation and the immigrant analysis should not be assumed to apply to it one for one.

Why it matters

This is where most close EB-1A cases are decided. Officers are allowed to look at quality, context and consistency, and to conclude that evidence that technically meets a criterion does not show standing at the top. A petition that never addresses this step directly leaves the officer to fill the gap alone.

It is also the step where the petitioner can do the most with argument and context: showing how selective an honor is, how rare a role is, and how the recognition was received by people in the field. Documents that only prove an item exists rarely persuade at this stage.

How USCIS evaluates it

The whole record, read together

The officer reads all the evidence as one record, not criterion by criterion. The question is whether the combination shows acclaim that is national or international in scope, sustained over time, and recognized in the field.

Relative standing

The test is comparative. The officer asks how the person stands against others in the same field: who holds similar awards, roles or publications, and whether this person is ahead of them. Evidence of absolute activity (many papers, many talks) is weighed against how the field normally behaves.

Sustained over time

Acclaim has to continue up to the date of filing. A major recognition from many years ago with little since can be read as a past peak, while recognition that has accumulated over several years reads as sustained.

Quality over quantity

A handful of strong, independent items usually outweighs a long list of routine ones. An officer can discount items that show participation but not selection, for example invitations that anyone can accept or awards that every entrant receives.

Inconsistencies count

Conflicting dates, titles that differ between documents, or letters that repeat each other word for word can weaken confidence in the rest of the record, even when each document would stand alone.

In AAO decisions

2,473 of 6,501 AAO decisions published in the Merito AAO Explorer mention this term (as of October 21, 2026).

In our corpus the decision text often states first how many of the ten criteria were met and then turns to whether the whole record shows standing at the top of the field.

“Where a petitioner meets these initial evidence requirements, we then consider the totality of the material provided in a final merits determination and assess whether the record shows sustained national or international acclaim and demonstrates that the individual is among the small percentage at the very top of the field of endeavor.”

“To merit approval, the record - as a whole - must establish a petitioner's "sustained national or international acclaim" and recognized achievements placing him or her among the small percentage at the very top of his or her field.”

“Beneficiary had a major, internationally recognized award, nor did it demonstrate the Beneficiary warranted a favorable decision within the final merits determination.”

The count describes what the decisions discuss. It says nothing about how any single case turns out.

Search these decisions in the AAO Explorer

A practical example

A software engineer submits a patent, an invited conference talk, a paid judging role for a hackathon and an interview in a trade magazine. Each fits a criterion on paper. At the final merits stage the officer asks how many engineers hold similar patents, how selective the talk and the judging role are, and whether the magazine is a major outlet. The record answers none of those questions, so the officer concludes it does not show standing ahead of peers. A response that supplies the missing comparisons, such as acceptance rates, the number of patents in the field and the outlet's readership, speaks directly to the step.

A common misconception

Final merits is not a second, secret list of requirements. It is the same question the statute asks, applied to the record as a whole, and it can be answered with evidence like any other part of the case.

How to document it

  • Selectivity data for each major item

    Acceptance rates, number of applicants, number of recipients, size of the committee, or the number of people eligible.

  • Independent coverage and citations

    Material about the work from people who are not connected to the petitioner, with dates and outlet standing.

  • Comparison with peers

    Publicly available figures about others in the field at the same level, for example typical citation counts, salary ranges or role titles.

  • A dated timeline

    Recognition shown year by year to the date of filing, so that the sustained part of the standard is visible.

  • Letters that explain, not only praise

    Each letter should state what the person did, who adopted it, what changed and how the writer knows.

  • A short argument section

    A part of the cover letter that walks through the whole record and says why, taken together, it meets the standard, referring to exhibits.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Rehearse the second look with the Officer Simulator

Last reviewed October 21, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.