Skip to content
Merito
In this section

Two-step analysis

EB-1AHow USCIS decides

6 min read

In short

The two-step analysis is how USCIS reads an EB-1A (extraordinary ability) petition. Step one asks whether the evidence satisfies at least three of the ten criteria in the regulation, or shows a one-time major award. Step two, the final merits determination, looks at all of the evidence together and asks whether the person has sustained national or international acclaim and stands among the small percentage at the very top of the field.

Also known as: Kazarian two-part test · two-part review · criteria count and final merits

Where it applies

  • It applies to every EB-1A petition on Form I-140, including self-petitions, and to appeals of EB-1A denials to the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO). The regulation behind step one is 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3); the framework for the two steps comes from the Ninth Circuit's 2010 decision in Kazarian v. USCIS, which USCIS adopted in its Policy Manual for officers everywhere, not only in the Ninth Circuit.
  • The same structure is used when officers write a request for evidence (RFE) or a denial: first they say which criteria they accept or reject, then they explain, separately, why the whole record does or does not show standing at the top of the field. The O-1A visa has its own criteria and a lower standard, but the habit of counting criteria first and judging the whole record second carries over in how many petitions are prepared.

Why it matters

Meeting three criteria does not win an EB-1A case. It only opens the second look. A large share of the reasoning in denials and AAO dismissals sits in step two: the officer accepts that three criteria were met on their wording and still concludes that the record does not show the person at the very top of the field.

That changes how a petition should be built. A file organized only to hit three criteria is built for half of the test. The other half needs context an officer can weigh: who else does this work, how the person compares to them, how long the recognition has lasted, and whether independent people outside the person's own circle noticed the work.

How USCIS evaluates it

Step one: does the evidence meet a criterion?

For each criterion the person claims, the officer decides whether the documents satisfy the wording of the regulation. The criteria include awards, membership, published material, judging, original contributions, scholarly articles, exhibitions, a leading or critical role, high pay and commercial success. Step one is a count against the regulation's plain language: the officer is not supposed to add requirements that the regulation does not state, which is the lesson of Kazarian. If fewer than three criteria are met and there is no one-time major award, the petition fails here.

Step two: the final merits determination

If three criteria are met, the officer reviews the entire record, including evidence that met a criterion and evidence that did not, and decides whether it shows sustained national or international acclaim and a place among the small percentage at the very top of the field. This is where the quality of the evidence matters: whether an award is national or internal, whether a judging role is selective, whether press coverage is independent, whether letters come from people who know the work but not the person.

The standard of proof

The standard is preponderance of the evidence: it must be more likely than not that the person qualifies. It is not proof beyond doubt, and a petition does not need every document to be perfect. It does need the record to be consistent: a role described one way in a letter and another way in a contract weakens everything around it.

What counts as the field

Officers compare the person to others in the same field and at the same level. Evidence that shows the person is recognized outside one employer, one institution or one city carries more weight than evidence that is only internal. The petition should say what the field is and use evidence that describes the field's own standards.

Where the steps show up in writing

An RFE or a decision usually has a section per criterion, then a separate section on the final merits. Reading it that way helps the response: if all three criteria were accepted, the response should be about the overall picture, not about the criteria again.

In AAO decisions

2,053 of 6,501 AAO decisions published in the Merito AAO Explorer mention this term (as of October 21, 2026).

“Given the structure of the regulations and the two-step analysis described in Kazarian, the satisfaction of three evidentiary criteria alone does not automatically or presumptively establish eligibility.”

“With eligibility under these two additional criteria, the Petitioner satisfied part one of the two-step adjudicative process described in Kazarian and has overcome the sole basis for the denial of his petition.”

“This case discusses a two-part review where the documentation is first counted and then, if fulfilling the required number of criteria, considered in the context of a final merits determination.”

The count describes what the decisions discuss. It says nothing about how any single case turns out.

Search these decisions in the AAO Explorer

A practical example

A researcher files evidence for four criteria: a conference best-paper award, reviewer invitations for three journals, news coverage of a lab result, and eight published papers. At step one the officer accepts three of the four. At step two the officer notes that the award is from a small workshop, the reviewing is for journals of modest standing, and the news coverage is about the employer. The officer concludes that the record does not show the person is among the small percentage at the top of the field. A stronger version of the same file keeps the same documents but adds independent evidence that places each one in context: how selective the award is, how many reviewers a journal invites, and who else has been recognized in the same way.

A common misconception

Three criteria is not a finish line. It is the entry to a second review in which the same documents are weighed again, together, against the standard of the very top of the field.

How to document it

  • A criteria map

    One table that lists the criteria you rely on and, beside each, the exhibits that prove it. Keep to the criteria that are strong; a weak fourth or fifth criterion can distract from three solid ones.

  • Proof for each claimed criterion, in the form the regulation names

    For published material: the article with its title, date and author plus the outlet's circulation or standing. For judging: the invitation or confirmation and evidence of what was judged. For awards: the rules, the selection process and the field of candidates.

  • Evidence of the field and the comparison group

    Rankings, membership counts, acceptance rates, the number of people who hold a similar role. This is what lets an officer see how selective each item is.

  • Independent expert letters

    Letters from recognized people who are not your collaborators or supervisors, each describing specific work, what changed because of it and how they know of it.

  • A timeline of recognition

    A dated chronology that shows recognition over several years and up to the filing date, since the standard is sustained acclaim.

  • Consistency checks

    Titles, dates and role descriptions that match across the CV, letters, contracts and exhibits.

  • A short cover letter organized around both steps

    One part that proves the criteria and one part that argues the whole record, with exhibit references in both.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

See where your evidence stands against both steps in the Merito Score

Last reviewed October 21, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.