Skip to content
Merito
In this section

Kazarian v. USCIS

EB-1ACase law

4 min read

In short

Kazarian v. USCIS is a 2010 Ninth Circuit decision about EB-1A petitions. It held that officers may not add requirements to a listed criterion that the regulation does not contain, and described the two-step reading that USCIS now follows: count the criteria first, judge the whole record second.

Also known as: Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 · Kazarian

Where it applies

  • It is cited throughout EB-1A adjudication, in USCIS policy guidance and in AAO decisions, including for petitioners who live outside the Ninth Circuit. The citation is 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010), and the pages most often cited are 1119 and 1120.
  • Its influence is mostly on how petitions are reviewed rather than on a particular fact pattern. Petitioners cite it when arguing that a criterion was read too strictly, and officers cite it when they move from counting criteria to the overall judgment.

Why it matters

It is the source of the two-step analysis. Understanding it explains why an officer can accept three criteria and still deny the petition, and why a response to an RFE can legitimately argue that the officer added a requirement the regulation does not state.

It also marks the limit of that argument. The court did not make EB-1A easier to win; it separated two questions. A petition that wins on the first can still lose on the second.

How USCIS evaluates it

Step one under Kazarian

The officer decides whether the evidence meets the regulation's wording for at least three criteria, without adding extra tests of quality that the regulation does not state. The court found that the agency had imposed requirements beyond the regulation's text in that case.

Step two under Kazarian

If the criteria are met, the officer judges the evidence as a whole for sustained national or international acclaim and standing at the top of the field. The AAO's decisions in our corpus refer to this as the final merits determination and cite the court's pages 1119 and 1120.

The result in the case

The court found that the agency had added requirements, but it upheld the denial of Kazarian's petition anyway. It did not hold that the petitioner had qualified.

How the AAO uses it today

In our corpus the decision is cited when the AAO explains the structure of its review, and in some decisions to explain why it need not reach the second step because the first was not met.

Outside the Ninth Circuit

A circuit court's decision does not bind agency practice everywhere, but USCIS adopted the two-step approach in its Policy Manual, so petitioners everywhere can rely on the structure.

In AAO decisions

2,055 of 6,501 AAO decisions published in the Merito AAO Explorer mention this term (as of October 21, 2026).

“As a result, we need not provide the type of final merits determination referenced in Kazarian, 596 F.3d at 1119-20.”

“Thus, Kazarian sets forth a two-part approach where the evidence is first counted and then considered in the context of a final merits determination.”

The count describes what the decisions discuss. It says nothing about how any single case turns out.

Search these decisions in the AAO Explorer

A practical example

A denial says authored papers do not count because they were not published in major journals, although the criterion asks for scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major media. A response can cite Kazarian to say the officer added a requirement, and then should also address the final merits, because winning the point does not by itself win the case.

A common misconception

Kazarian did not lower the bar. It stopped extra tests at the criteria step and confirmed that the overall judgment still has to be passed.

Common problems

  • Citing it without the final merits

    A response that wins an argument about an added requirement but does not address the whole record leaves the second step unanswered.

  • Citing it for a requirement that is in the regulation

    The decision protects against requirements the regulation does not state. It does not remove requirements the regulation does state, such as the content of a criterion.

  • Treating it as binding everywhere

    It is a circuit court decision, and its structure was adopted by USCIS guidance. State it that way and cite the guidance too.

  • Quoting the wrong pages

    The pages cited in decisions are 1119 and 1120. Mark them in the exhibit.

How to document it

  • A criterion-by-criterion table that quotes the regulation

    For each criterion claimed, the regulation's exact words beside the evidence that meets them, so any extra test an officer applies stands out.

  • A separate final merits section

    A part of the cover letter that argues the whole record and cites exhibits, independent of the criteria table.

  • A response that names the added requirement

    If an RFE or a denial adds a test the regulation does not state, say which words of the regulation it adds to, and cite the decision and pages.

  • The full decision as an exhibit when you cite it

    The opinion at 596 F.3d 1115, with the relevant pages marked.

  • Evidence for the second step too

    Context, comparison and independent recognition, since the court's reading keeps the overall judgment in place.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Search how the AAO applied it in the AAO Decisions Explorer

Last reviewed October 21, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.