In short
Judging the work of others is one of the kinds of evidence listed in the EB-1A regulation. It covers a person's participation, alone or as part of a panel, in evaluating the work of others in the same or an allied field, such as reviewing a manuscript or sitting on a dissertation committee. The evidence has to show that the evaluating actually took place, not only that it was offered.
Also known as: Judging criterion · Participation as a judge · Peer review criterion

Where it applies
- The term belongs to the EB-1A category, the first-preference group for people of extraordinary ability. The statute describes that group as people with sustained national or international acclaim whose achievements are recognized in the field through extensive documentation. The regulation at 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(iv) lists judging as one kind of evidence that can be offered toward that showing.
- The regulation speaks of judging the work of others "in the same or an allied field of specification" as the one claimed. The Policy Manual repeats that wording and adds examples: journal peer review, review of abstracts or papers for scholarly conferences, service on a Ph.D. dissertation committee, and peer review for government research funding programs. Those examples are illustrations, not a closed list.
Why it matters
Judging is one of several routes the regulation offers, so a weak or unclear showing here leaves the petitioner with less to rely on elsewhere. The wording is plain: an officer asks whether the person acted as a judge. A record that proves a role in evaluating other people's work meets that wording directly, while a record that only suggests availability or interest does not.
The criterion also matters because of what it is not. Kazarian v. USCIS shows that an adjudicator may not add requirements the regulation never states. At the same time, the court noted that a point it removed from the criterion stage might still be relevant to a final merits determination, the later weighing of the whole record. Both layers can therefore affect how judging evidence is read.
How USCIS evaluates it
Was there actual judging?
The Policy Manual says the petitioner must show more than an invitation. The person must have actually taken part in judging the work of others. Its example is a request from a journal to review a submission, paired with proof that the review was finished. A request alone shows that someone asked; the completed review shows that evaluation happened. Documents that cover both steps give the officer a full picture.
Same or allied field
The regulation ties the judging to the same or an allied field of specification as the one in which classification is sought. An officer therefore compares what was judged with the field named in the petition. A record that states the field clearly and shows that the reviewed manuscripts, abstracts or proposals fall within it lets that comparison be made without guesswork.
Evidence of the role itself
The Policy Manual points to different documents for different roles. For a dissertation committee, it mentions departmental records showing that the committee makes the final judgment on whether a candidate's body of work meets the requirements for a doctoral degree. The pattern is that the document should show what the person decided or evaluated, and in what capacity.
No added affiliation test
In Kazarian, the AAO discounted review of graduate diploma works at the person's own university and asked for outside review. The Ninth Circuit held that this rested on an improper understanding of the regulation, because nothing in it makes the outcome depend on which university the judge is affiliated with. The court added that the AAO may not unilaterally impose a novel evidentiary requirement.
A practical example
This is an invented illustration. A materials scientist wants to rely on judging. The file contains emails from two journal editors asking for reviews, editor confirmations that the reports were submitted, a program committee notice listing the person as an abstract reviewer for a scholarly conference, and a dated list tying each item to the field named in the petition. An officer can see the request, the completed work and the subject area for each entry, and can then move on to the weight of the whole record.
A common misconception
One mistaken reading is that an invitation to review or serve on a committee is enough. The Policy Manual says the petitioner must show that the person was invited and also actually participated in judging, for example through a journal's request plus confirmation that the review was completed.
Common problems
Invitations without completion
A file may hold requests to review but nothing showing that any review was delivered. Because the Policy Manual calls for proof of actual participation, a stack of invitations leaves a gap an officer can see. The record then shows willingness to judge but not the judging itself, which is the thing the regulation names.
Unclear field or subject matter
If a document says only that the person served as a reviewer, without saying what kind of work was reviewed, the connection to the same or an allied field cannot be checked. A list of roles with no description of the material evaluated leaves the officer to infer the link rather than read it.
Roles described only by the person
A self-written summary of reviewing activity, with no third-party record behind it, gives an officer nothing independent to check. The Policy Manual's examples rely on journal requests and departmental records, which are documents created by the institutions involved rather than by the person describing the role.
How to document it
Request or invitation from the journal, conference, committee or funding program
It shows who asked the person to judge and what kind of work was involved.
Proof that the judging was completed
A submission confirmation or thank-you from the editor shows the person did the evaluation, which the Policy Manual treats as necessary.
Departmental or institutional records for committee service
For dissertation committees, records showing that the committee made the final judgment on the candidate's work show the nature of the role.
A short dated table of judging activities
Listing each item with the field, the date and the exhibit that proves it helps an officer follow the record.
Official sources
- 8 CFR 204.5 (petitions for employment-based immigrants) — accessed October 22, 2026
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 (Extraordinary Ability) — accessed October 22, 2026
- Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010) — accessed October 22, 2026
- 8 U.S.C. 1153 (INA 203, allocation of immigrant visas) — accessed October 22, 2026
Use it in Merito
Organize your exhibits in the Evidence BinderLast reviewed October 22, 2026
