In short
Peer review is the practice in which a person with expertise in a field reads and assesses the work of others in that field, such as a manuscript or a proposal, and gives a judgment on it. In the EB-1A regulation, this kind of activity falls under the criterion about participation, individually or on a panel, as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied field. The term itself is an everyday label, not a defined legal term.
Also known as: Manuscript review · Referee activity · Judging the work of others

Where it applies
- Merito's editorial classification places peer review in the EB-1A, O-1A and EB-2 NIW categories. The source text that names it most directly is the EB-1A regulation at 8 CFR 204.5, which lists, among the kinds of initial evidence, "evidence of the alien's participation, either individually or on a panel, as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied field of specification for which classification is sought." Peer review is one common way a person might describe that kind of activity.
- The regulation lists that item as one of several. A petition for an alien of extraordinary ability must include evidence of a one-time major achievement or at least three of the listed items. Reviewing is therefore one possible item among others, listed separately from the authorship of scholarly articles. The sources given here do not describe how the O-1A or EB-2 NIW categories treat reviewing, so this entry does not say how it works there.
Why it matters
The regulation asks for evidence of participation as a judge. A statement that a person reviews for journals is an assertion, and the Policy Manual says that simply going on record without supporting documentary evidence is not sufficient to meet the burden of proof. The burden always falls on the person seeking the benefit and never shifts to USCIS.
The standard of proof in most proceedings is the preponderance of the evidence: the claim must be shown to be more likely than not true. For reviewing, that means the documents should be relevant, probative and credible. The manual describes credibility, reliability and authenticity as the factors USCIS considers in assigning weight to a document, so the way the reviewing record is built bears on how much weight it can carry.
How USCIS evaluates it
Matching the regulation's wording
The criterion speaks of participation as a judge of the work of others, individually or on a panel, in the same or an allied field as the one for which classification is sought. Reviewing a manuscript, a proposal or a submission is a form of judging someone else's work. Whether a given activity fits is a question about the facts the documents establish, and the regulation itself does not mention journals or any particular kind of reviewing.
Credibility, reliability and authenticity
The Policy Manual says that in weighing a document, USCIS considers its credibility, reliability and authenticity. It adds that the circumstances in which a record was created, such as whether it was made at the time of the event and as part of the regular conduct of business, may affect its weight. These are general statements about documentary evidence, and they apply to whatever is submitted to show reviewing work.
Letters and statements about reviewing
The manual describes what affidavits should contain: the affiant's relationship to the parties, the basis of the affiant's knowledge, and the facts the affiant knows rather than mere conclusory statements. It says affidavits lacking those elements may not receive significant weight, and that little weight may be given when the affiant lacks direct knowledge. A statement from an editor or program chair is a different kind of document from a sworn affidavit, but these points show what the manual treats as the marks of a statement with substance.
A practical example
The following is an invented illustration. A materials scientist claims reviewing as one of several items. The file includes email invitations from two journal editors, each dated when the manuscript was assigned, plus a letter from an editor stating the field of the manuscripts, the number reviewed over three years, and how the editor knows of the work. The scientist's CV lists the same two journals. A reader can follow the claim from the CV line to the invitations and the editor's account, and the journal names and dates match across the three documents.
A common misconception
One mistaken reading is that a long list of journals on a CV is enough to show judging. The sources say instead that going on record without supporting documentary evidence is not sufficient to meet the burden of proof, and that the person seeking the benefit must submit relevant, probative and credible evidence.
Common problems
Assertion without documents
A claim of reviewing that rests only on the person's own statement is the situation the Policy Manual describes when it says that going on record without supporting documentary evidence is not sufficient. The reader sees a claim and no record beneath it.
Conclusory letters
A letter that praises a reviewer in general terms, without saying what the writer knows firsthand or what was reviewed, resembles what the manual calls mere conclusory statements. The manual says statements lacking the basis of knowledge and specific facts may not be given significant weight.
Details that do not match
The manual calls for scrutiny of evidence for consistency with the claims made. A journal name, a date or a scope of reviewing that differs between the CV, the letters and the invitations is a visible gap between documents.
How to document it
Original invitations or assignment emails
These are records made when the reviewing took place, and the manual says the circumstances of creation may affect weight. They can show the sender, date and request.
A letter from an editor, chair or program officer
A statement that gives the writer's role, how the writer knows of the reviewing, and specific facts rather than general praise matches the elements the manual describes for affidavits.
Confirmation of the journal, conference or panel
Material that identifies the venue and the field helps connect the activity to the same or allied field named in the petition.
A dated list of reviews
A list with journal names and dates, cross-checked against the invitations, lets the reader see that the CV and the exhibits agree.
Official sources
- 8 CFR 204.5 (petitions for employment-based immigrants) — accessed October 23, 2026
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 1, Part E, Chapter 6 (Evidence) — accessed October 23, 2026
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 1, Part E, Chapter 4 (Burden and Standards of Proof) — accessed October 23, 2026
Use it in Merito
Build your evidence checklistLast reviewed October 23, 2026
