Skip to content
Merito
In this section

RFE

Request for Evidence (RFE)

EB-1AO-1ANIWThe process

4 min read

In short

A Request for Evidence is a written notice from USCIS saying the petition as filed does not yet show eligibility. It lists what is missing, explains why, and gives a date by which the response has to be received.

Also known as: RFE · Form I-797E notice

Where it applies

  • Most USCIS filings, including Form I-140 for EB-1A and the national interest waiver, and Form I-129 for O-1A. The rule is 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8), and the USCIS Policy Manual's chapter on evidence (Volume 1, Part E, Chapter 6) describes how officers use it.
  • An RFE is different from a Notice of Intent to Deny (NOID), which says USCIS is inclined to deny and explains why. Both give the person a chance to respond, but they carry different expectations about what the response has to do.

Why it matters

An RFE is not a denial. It is the officer's statement of what prevented approval on the file as it stands, and the response is usually the last chance to add evidence before a decision. The response date is firm and the response is one submission.

Because the RFE says what the officer found missing, it is also the most direct guide to what to do next. A good response answers the specific points in the notice instead of restating the original argument.

How USCIS evaluates it

When an officer issues one

An RFE issues when initial evidence is missing, or when the evidence filed does not establish eligibility. The notice states what is requested and the response date; the regulation allows no more than 12 weeks.

What the response must be

The response has to address every point of the notice and be submitted together, at one time. Under the regulation, sending only part of the requested evidence is treated as a request for a decision on the record.

Eligibility at filing

Evidence in response must show eligibility that existed when the petition was filed. A later achievement, such as an award won after filing, does not cure an earlier gap.

What happens after

The officer reviews the response with the original file. If it resolves the issues the petition can be approved; if not, USCIS may deny it, or may issue a Notice of Intent to Deny if there is derogatory information the person has a right to answer.

Assertions versus documents

The decisions in our corpus show a recurring problem: statements in a response letter that the record does not back with documents. A statement should point to the exhibit that supports it.

In AAO decisions

3,213 of 6,501 AAO decisions published in the Merito AAO Explorer mention this term (as of October 21, 2026).

A wording that recurs in decisions that discuss a response to an RFE is that statements in the response were not accompanied by documents, or by a pointer to evidence already in the record.

“Similarly, the Petitioner made these same claims in his response cover letter to a request for evidence but did not offer documentation or identify evidence contained in the record to support those assertions.”

“He asserts that he explained his proposed endeavor in detail in the initial filing and in response to the request for evidence (RFE), establishing both the substantial merit and national importance.”

“In the request for evidence (RFE), the director concluded that the letters of support confirmed the petitioner's talent, but did not establish her leading or critical role.”

The count describes what the decisions discuss. It says nothing about how any single case turns out.

Search these decisions in the AAO Explorer

A practical example

An EB-1A petition receives an RFE that says the published material about the person did not name the person or show the standing of the outlet. The response adds the outlets' own descriptions of their circulation, certified translations, and a letter confirming the dates of publication, with a short table that matches each article to the criterion's wording.

A common misconception

An RFE does not mean the petition is failing. It means the officer cannot approve on the file as it stands. A focused, complete response often resolves it.

Common problems

  • Answering a different question

    The response argues the original case again instead of the points in the notice. Quote the officer’s point and answer it directly.

  • Sending the response in pieces

    The regulation treats a partial submission as a request for a decision on the record. Send everything together, before the response date.

  • New achievements offered as the cure

    Eligibility has to exist at filing. Newer items can support the story but do not fix a gap that existed then.

  • Statements with no exhibit

    A claim in the cover letter that is not tied to a document is weak. Each statement should point to an exhibit number.

  • Missing translations or incomplete copies

    Documents not in English need certified translations, and partial copies invite further questions.

How to document it

  • A point-by-point response table

    Each issue the officer raised, the answer, and the exhibit number that supports it.

  • New evidence for each gap

    Documents that fill exactly what the notice says is missing, not a general addition of material.

  • Original documents and translations

    Complete copies, with certified translations of anything not in English.

  • Proof of timing

    Dates that show the evidence existed at filing where eligibility depends on it.

  • A short cover letter

    Quote the notice's points, answer them in order and cite exhibits; leave out arguments that were already accepted.

  • A single, complete package

    Everything requested in one submission before the response date, with proof of delivery.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Break down a notice with the RFE Decoder

Last reviewed October 21, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.