Skip to content
Merito
In this section

RFE Response

EB-1AO-1AEB-2 NIWThe process

7 min read

In short

An RFE response is what a petitioner sends back to USCIS after receiving a Request for Evidence, a written notice asking for more proof or information before a decision. It is submitted within the deadline stated in the notice and addresses the evidence or issues the notice names. Once sent, it becomes part of the record the officer uses to decide the petition.

Also known as: Response to Request for Evidence · RFE reply

Where it applies

  • The term belongs to the process surrounding EB-1A, O-1A and EB-2 NIW petitions, as classified in Merito's own editorial tags. The rules for requests for evidence sit in 8 CFR 103.2, the general regulation on submitting and deciding benefit requests. That regulation lets USCIS, when required initial evidence is missing or the evidence does not establish eligibility, ask for the missing or additional material within a period it sets.
  • The regulation also describes a related notice, the notice of intent to deny, which states the basis for a proposed denial and asks for a response. It is answered under the same section, and the rules on how to respond cover both notices together. A request for evidence is communicated by regular or electronic mail, and it must specify the type of evidence required, or the bases for the proposed denial in the case of a notice of intent to deny, so that the petitioner has adequate notice and sufficient information to respond.

Why it matters

The response is the petitioner's chance to answer the officer's stated concerns before a decision is made. The regulation says a benefit request is denied if the record evidence establishes ineligibility, and the Policy Manual says an officer evaluates all evidence submitted, including in response to a request for evidence, before deciding. Whatever the response contains or leaves out is part of what the officer weighs.

Timing and completeness also carry consequences. If a petitioner fails to respond by the required date, the regulation allows the request to be summarily denied as abandoned, denied based on the record, or denied for both reasons. Additional time to respond may not be granted, so the deadline in the notice is the working limit.

The response also bears on later steps. If the petition is denied, the written decision explains the reasons, and the regulations describe appeals and motions that follow. An appeal must identify specifically any erroneous conclusion of law or statement of fact, so the record built at the response stage shapes what can later be pointed to.

How USCIS evaluates it

Deadline set by the notice

The notice states a response deadline. The regulation caps the response period for a request for evidence at twelve weeks and for a notice of intent to deny at thirty days, and it says extra time may not be granted. An officer therefore reads the response against the date written in the notice, not against a period the petitioner assumes.

Three ways to respond

Within the response period, the regulation lets the petitioner submit a complete response with everything requested, submit a partial response and ask for a decision on the record, or withdraw the benefit request. The choice is the petitioner's to make; the regulation only describes the options and their effects.

Everything together, with the original notice

The regulation requires all requested materials to be submitted together at one time, along with the original request for evidence or notice of intent to deny. It also states that submitting only some of the requested evidence is considered a request for a decision on the record. A response that mirrors the notice item by item makes it easier to see what was supplied.

Eligibility at the time of filing

A petitioner must establish eligibility at the time of filing and must continue to be eligible through adjudication. The regulation says a benefit request is denied where evidence submitted in response to a request does not establish filing eligibility at the time the request was filed. Evidence in a response is therefore read for what it shows about the situation when the petition was filed.

Gaps and missing material

When a petitioner asks for a decision on the existing record, a decision is issued on that record. The regulation states that failure to submit requested evidence that precludes a material line of inquiry is grounds for denying the request. Where a required document does not exist or cannot be obtained, the regulation requires the petitioner to demonstrate that, and to submit secondary evidence pertinent to the facts at issue. If secondary evidence also does not exist or cannot be obtained, the petitioner must show the unavailability of both and submit two or more affidavits, sworn or affirmed by persons who are not parties to the petition and who have direct personal knowledge of the event and circumstances.

In AAO decisions

810 of 6,501 AAO decisions published in the Merito AAO Explorer mention this term (as of October 22, 2026).

In the AAO sentences provided, petitioners and decisions refer back to the RFE response as part of the record, for example when a petitioner points to evidence from the initial petition and the response together, or when the AAO cites letters submitted in the response. In one remanded matter the petitioner argued that the earlier decision gave essentially no analysis of the evidence in the petition and response.

“The Petitioner asserts that SCOPS made its determination as to national importance with "essentially no analysis of the specific evidence submitted in the Petition and RFE Response.”

“On appeal, the Petitioner asserts that the proposed endeavor has national importance based on ultimately "All Evidence from Initial Petition and RFE Response," discussing in particular his business plan, the copies of publications providing generalized information regarding the automotive industry, and opinion letters.”

“These conclusions are plainly contradicted by the letters of recommendation submitted in the RFE Response, which both report how the authors of these letters and their researchers relied "more heavily" upon [the petitioner's] research and consider his work to be original contributions of major significance to the field .”

The count describes what the decisions discuss. It says nothing about how any single case turns out.

Search these decisions in the AAO Explorer

A practical example

This is an invented illustration. A researcher who filed a petition receives a request for evidence stating that the submitted letters do not describe how the research has been used by others. The notice sets a deadline. The researcher gathers new letters and documents that describe specific uses of the work, places them in one package with a copy of the original notice, and sends everything together before the date in the notice. A short index lists each item the notice asked for and the exhibit that answers it, so the officer can follow the record without searching.

A common misconception

One mistaken reading is that a petitioner can ask for more time when a response cannot be finished by the deadline. The regulation says instead that the response period in a request for evidence may not exceed twelve weeks, the period in a notice of intent to deny may not exceed thirty days, and additional time may not be granted.

Common problems

  • Answering only part of the notice

    A notice may list several items. The regulation says that submitting only some of the requested evidence is considered a request for a decision on the record. A response that leaves a listed item unanswered can therefore be read as asking the officer to decide without it.

  • Missing the deadline

    The notice states a date, and the regulation says that failing to respond by the required date allows the benefit request to be summarily denied as abandoned, denied on the record, or both. A response that is complete in content but sent after the date does not fit the response period the regulation describes.

  • Leaving out the original notice

    The regulation requires the original request for evidence or notice of intent to deny to be submitted along with the requested materials. A package without it does not follow the stated submission requirement.

How to document it

  • The original notice

    The regulation requires it to be submitted with the response, and it also lets the officer match each reply to the stated concern.

  • A response index keyed to the notice

    A list that pairs each item the notice names with the exhibit that answers it shows the officer where each answer sits in the package.

  • Primary documents for each requested item

    Documents of the type the notice names show directly what the notice asked about, and they form part of the record the officer evaluates.

  • Secondary evidence where a required document is unavailable

    The regulation requires the petitioner to demonstrate that the required document does not exist or cannot be obtained, and to submit secondary evidence pertinent to the facts at issue.

  • Affidavits where secondary evidence is also unavailable

    The regulation then calls for a showing that both the document and the secondary evidence are unavailable, plus two or more affidavits from persons who are not parties to the petition and have direct personal knowledge of the event.

  • Dated evidence tied to the filing date

    Documents with clear dates show what was true when the petition was filed, which is the point at which eligibility must be established.

  • Proof of the submission date and the deadline

    A record of when the package was sent next to the date in the notice shows the response was made within the period the notice allowed.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Decode a Request for Evidence

Last reviewed October 22, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.