In short
Eligibility at the time of filing is a label for the idea that the facts and evidence supporting a petition are tied to the date the request was submitted. Merito uses it for EB-1A, O-1A and EB-2 NIW petitions. The sources supplied for this entry do not state the rule in a sentence of their own, so this entry describes the burden, evidence and decision rules that surround a filed request.
Also known as: Time-of-filing rule · Eligibility as of the filing date

Where it applies
- Merito classifies the term under EB-1A, O-1A and EB-2 NIW. That grouping is an editorial orientation, not a statement that every rule works identically in each category. The decisions behind this entry involve two of them: Kazarian concerns an extraordinary ability petition on Form I-140, and Dhanasar concerns a national interest waiver sought within the EB-2 classification.
- Neither decision, nor the Policy Manual chapter on burden and standards, sets out a time-of-filing rule in its own words. This entry therefore does not cite a regulation for the rule itself. What the sources do show is that a filed petition has a date, that a record is assembled around it, and that the decision and any appeal answer what that record contains. Kazarian recites a filing date of December 31, 2003, and Dhanasar describes the petitioner's position as of filing.
Why it matters
The burden of proof to establish eligibility always falls on the person requesting the benefit, according to the Policy Manual, and it never shifts to USCIS. A petition is the requestor's way of meeting that burden, so the date of filing marks the point at which the supporting facts are put forward. Nothing in the sources says the agency will go looking for facts the filing leaves out.
Kazarian shows how this plays out when a record falls short. The petitioner presented two of the types of evidence in the regulation, and the regulation requires three. The court observed that he appeared to be a well-respected, promising physicist who might have qualified under a different classification, but he had applied for extraordinary ability. The decision turned on what the petition contained and which category it claimed.
Dhanasar shows the favorable side. The decision describes the petitioner's degrees, his work as a postdoctoral research associate when the petition was filed, and his research record, and then finds that the record shows each element by a preponderance of the evidence. The facts that mattered were documented in the record before the decision.
How USCIS evaluates it
Starting from the requestor's burden
The Policy Manual describes a prima facie case as one where the requestor has come forward with facts and evidence showing, at a minimum and without further inquiry, initial eligibility. That description centers on what the requestor submitted. The chapter adds that in some cases an officer must then decide whether approval or denial is appropriate as a matter of discretion, so showing eligibility is the first question and not always the last.
The standard of proof
Most administrative immigration proceedings use the preponderance of the evidence standard. Under it, relevant, probative and credible evidence that makes a claim probably true or more likely than not satisfies the standard, even if some doubt remains. The Policy Manual says that when the standard is not met, an officer may request more evidence, issue a notice of intent to deny, or deny the case. Dhanasar applies the same standard to its three elements.
Counting evidence against the regulation
Kazarian describes two routes in the extraordinary ability regulation: a one-time major award, or at least three of the listed types of evidence. The court measured the petition against that text, finding two types where three were required. Dhanasar likewise states elements the petitioner must show: substantial merit and national importance of the endeavor, being well positioned to advance it, and that waiving the job offer and labor certification benefits the United States on balance.
Written reasons and review
When USCIS denies a petition, 8 CFR 103.3 requires the officer to explain the specific reasons in writing. An appeal and any briefs become part of the record of proceeding. The regulation also provides for summary dismissal when the appealing party fails to identify specifically any erroneous conclusion of law or statement of fact. A written denial and an appeal both point back to what the filed record did or did not show.
A practical example
This is an invented illustration, not a statement of any rule. A researcher files a petition on a stated date. The file contains an employment letter dated the same month, two publication records and a contract. A reader going through it can ask of each document what fact it establishes and whether the document itself carries a date. A contract with no date, or a letter that describes a role without saying when it began, leaves that question open. A file where each exhibit is dated and tied to a specific claim lets a reader see the facts the petition rests on.
A common misconception
One mistaken reading is that once a petition is filed, USCIS must find whatever is missing from it. The Policy Manual says the burden of proof always falls solely on the benefit requestor and never shifts to USCIS, and Kazarian shows a petition measured by the evidence actually presented.
Common problems
Claims without evidence behind them
In Kazarian, a colleague's letter said the petitioner's self-published textbook was certain to be required reading in many schools, yet the petitioner presented no evidence that the book was actually used in any class. A statement that rests on nothing in the record leaves an officer with no document to check it against. A filing is clearer when each assertion has an exhibit that shows the underlying fact.
Fewer types of evidence than the regulation lists
Kazarian turned on a count: two types of evidence presented, three required. The court also noted that the petitioner might have been able to qualify under a different classification. A record that is strong in general terms can still fall short of the specific text of the category claimed, so the match between category wording and evidence is a point a reader can check.
Missing links between the elements
Dhanasar sets out three elements, and its approval rests on the record showing each one. A file that documents the merit of an endeavor but says little about whether the person is well positioned to advance it leaves one element thinly supported. The gap is visible in the record whichever element is thin.
An appeal that does not name the error
Under 8 CFR 103.3, an appeal that fails to identify specifically any erroneous conclusion of law or statement of fact is subject to summary dismissal. A general statement of disagreement does not point to a particular conclusion in the decision. Naming the conclusion that is challenged ties the appeal to the written reasons for denial.
How to document it
A dated filing record
A copy of the filing and its receipt shows the date the request was submitted, which gives every other document in the file a reference point.
Dated primary documents for each claimed fact
Contracts, appointment letters, award notices and publication records show what happened and when, so a reader does not have to infer timing from a summary.
A claim-to-exhibit table
A table that lists each regulatory criterion or Dhanasar element beside the exhibits supporting it shows where each part of the standard is addressed.
Evidence of use or effect, not only praise
Kazarian noted that a letter praising a textbook was not backed by any showing of classroom use. Documents that show actual use, adoption or results give a claim something concrete behind it.
Consistent titles, dates and role descriptions
Matching details across the CV, letters and contracts let a reader follow one account of the person's position without conflicting versions.
The written decision, annotated, if one exists
Marking each stated reason in a denial against the exhibits it concerns shows which conclusions an appeal would need to identify specifically.
Official sources
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 1, Part E, Chapter 4 (Burden and Standards of Proof) — accessed October 23, 2026
- Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010) — accessed October 23, 2026
- Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016) — accessed October 23, 2026
- 8 CFR 103.3 (denials, appeals and certifications) — accessed October 23, 2026
Use it in Merito
Organize your exhibits in the Evidence BinderLast reviewed October 23, 2026
