In short
Substantial merit is the first half of the first prong of the Dhanasar test for a national interest waiver in EB-2 NIW cases. It asks whether the specific work the person proposes to do has real value in an area such as business, science, technology, culture, health, or education. It is judged on the endeavor itself, and the endeavor does not have to produce an immediate or measurable economic gain.
Also known as: Dhanasar prong one substantial merit · merit of the proposed endeavor · substantial merit and national importance (first prong)

Where it applies
- Substantial merit belongs to the EB-2 NIW category. The statute, 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(2)(B)(i), lets the waiver be granted when it is deemed to be in the national interest, and it waives the requirement that the person's services be sought by a U.S. employer. Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016), sets out the three-part framework that USCIS uses, and substantial merit sits inside the first prong, next to national importance.
- Dhanasar states that this framework applies after eligibility for EB-2 classification has been established. The Policy Manual chapter on advanced degree or exceptional ability repeats the same three prongs for officers. Substantial merit is therefore one element within a larger sequence: the person must first qualify for the underlying classification, then show the endeavor has merit and national importance, then show the other two prongs.
Why it matters
The first prong has two elements joined by the word "and." Dhanasar says the endeavor must have both substantial merit and national importance. A petition can describe valuable work and still fall short if the record does not also show national importance. In the AAO sentences supplied, one dismissal turns on national importance, not on merit.
Dhanasar also frames the first prong around the specific endeavor that the person proposes to undertake. That means the description of the work is the object of the analysis. Because the standard is a preponderance of the evidence, the record must make it more likely than not that the endeavor has the claimed merit, which makes the clarity of the description central.
How USCIS evaluates it
The endeavor is the subject
Dhanasar says the first prong focuses on the specific endeavor the foreign national proposes to undertake. The question is therefore about the work described in the record, not about the person's general profession or credentials. The person's qualifications are taken up under the second prong, which asks whether the person is well positioned to advance the endeavor.
A wide range of fields
Dhanasar says merit may be demonstrated in areas such as business, entrepreneurialism, science, technology, culture, health, or education. A 2024 AAO decision in the supplied sentences quotes this list. The list shows that merit is not limited to one kind of work, and a petition can point to whichever area fits the endeavor.
No requirement of economic impact
Dhanasar states that evidence of significant economic impact may be favorable but is not required, because merit may be established without immediate or quantifiable economic impact. It gives research, pure science, and the furtherance of human knowledge as examples that may qualify whether or not the results are likely to translate into economic benefits for the United States.
Why the word "intrinsic" was dropped
The earlier NYSDOT framework asked about "substantial intrinsic merit." Dhanasar said the term "intrinsic" added little to the analysis and was open to unnecessary subjective evaluation, though it noted the first prong had held up under adjudicative experience. The current wording asks about substantial merit without that qualifier.
Merit can be found where national importance is not
In Dhanasar itself, the AAO found that the petitioner's aerospace propulsion research had substantial merit because it aimed to advance scientific knowledge and further national security interests and U.S. competitiveness in the civil space sector. For the same petitioner's STEM teaching, it found substantial merit but concluded the record did not show the broader impact needed for national importance. The two elements were assessed separately.
In AAO decisions
3,313 of 6,501 AAO decisions published in the Merito AAO Explorer mention this term (as of October 22, 2026).
The AAO sentences supplied show the first prong headed as one question about substantial merit and national importance. In the 2025 dismissal, the stated reason is that the endeavor lacked national importance. The two sustained decisions describe or quote the endeavor, one a mathematics research project and the other the list of fields in which merit may be shown.
“Whether the Proposed Endeavor Has Substantial Merit and National Importance Upon reviewing the record, we conclude that the Petitioner's endeavor does not have national importance under the Dhanasar's first prong.”
“Whether the Proposed Endeavor Has Substantial Merit and National Importance The substantial merit of an endeavor "may be demonstrated in a range of areas such as business, entrepreneurialism, science, technology, culture, health, or education.”
“Whether the Proposed Endeavor Has Substantial Merit and National Importance The Petitioner proposes to continue his mathematics research as it relates to the development of new solutions for partial differential equations and for terminal problems in backward heat transfer.”
The count describes what the decisions discuss. It says nothing about how any single case turns out.
Search these decisions in the AAO ExplorerA practical example
This is an invented illustration. A researcher proposes to continue work on a method for detecting a plant disease earlier in the growing season. The petition describes the research question, the type of results expected, and the field it belongs to, and it attaches a published review article that explains why the problem matters to agriculture. Nothing in the file claims a dollar figure. Under Dhanasar, the absence of a quantified economic gain does not by itself prevent the endeavor from having merit, since research aimed at furthering knowledge may qualify. The separate question of national importance would still need its own evidence.
A common misconception
One mistaken reading is that an endeavor must promise a measurable economic payoff to have substantial merit. Dhanasar says instead that economic impact may be favorable but is not required, and that research, pure science, and the furtherance of human knowledge may qualify whether or not they are likely to translate into economic benefits.
Common problems
Treating merit as the whole first prong
A record may spend all its pages showing that the work is worthwhile and say little about national importance. Dhanasar requires both elements, so a file that proves only one leaves the other unsupported. The 2025 AAO dismissal in the supplied sentences turned on national importance.
Describing a field instead of an endeavor
Because the first prong focuses on the specific endeavor, a description that names only a profession or a broad field leaves the endeavor itself undefined. A reader cannot tell from such a description what exactly is proposed, so there is little for the evidence to attach to.
Presenting merit only through economic claims
Since Dhanasar says economic impact is not required, a file that rests merit only on projected revenue or jobs can leave out other bases the decision recognizes, such as advancing knowledge or health, educational, or cultural value. Economic effects may still be favorable where they exist.
Mixing the person's credentials into the merit discussion
The second prong is about whether the person is well positioned to advance the endeavor. Credentials and track record answer that question. When they are used to argue merit, the description of the endeavor itself may remain thin.
How to document it
A specific written description of the endeavor
A statement of what the person will do, in which field, and toward what aim gives the first prong a concrete object, since Dhanasar focuses on the specific endeavor.
Independent sources on the field's needs
Government reports, published reviews, or agency materials that explain why the problem the endeavor addresses matters can show merit without relying only on the petitioner's own words.
Expert letters that describe the work
Letters from people in the field are most useful when they explain the endeavor and its value specifically, rather than praising the person in general terms.
Research proposals, grant documents, or project plans
These show what the work aims to accomplish and in which area, such as science, health, or education.
A business plan, where the endeavor is a venture
A plan can explain objectives, though the Policy Manual says such plans should be supported by other independent evidence.
Evidence of non-economic value
Where the merit lies in knowledge, health, culture, or education, documents that show that value help, since Dhanasar says economic impact is not required.
A clear separation of merit and national importance
Organizing the exhibits so that each element has its own evidence lets a reader see that both parts of the first prong are addressed.
Official sources
- Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016) — accessed October 22, 2026
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5 (Advanced Degree or Exceptional Ability) — accessed October 22, 2026
- 8 U.S.C. 1153 (INA 203, allocation of immigrant visas) — accessed October 22, 2026
Use it in Merito
Map your case on the Case CanvasLast reviewed October 22, 2026
