Skip to content
Merito
In this section

Matter of Dhanasar

EB-2 NIWEB-2 NIW

6 min read

In short

Matter of Dhanasar is a 2016 precedent decision of the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) that sets out how USCIS reviews requests for a national interest waiver, which excuses the job offer and labor certification otherwise needed for EB-2 classification. It replaced an older test with three elements: the proposed endeavor has substantial merit and national importance, the person is well positioned to advance it, and on balance waiving the job offer would benefit the United States.

Also known as: Dhanasar decision · 26 I&N Dec. 884 · Dhanasar three-prong test

Where it applies

  • The decision belongs to the EB-2 NIW category. The statute, section 203(b)(2) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), makes visas available to members of the professions holding advanced degrees and to persons of exceptional ability, and subparagraph (B) lets the government waive the requirement that an employer in the United States seek the person's services. The statute does not define "national interest." Dhanasar supplies the analytical framework for that undefined phrase.
  • The decision also explains the order of questions. A petitioner who seeks the waiver must first show that the person qualifies as a member of the professions holding an advanced degree or as an individual of exceptional ability. Only after that does the three-element analysis apply. The decision uses "petitioners" for both employers and self-petitioners, and says the new framework was meant to fit both. The Policy Manual likewise describes the waiver as limited to the second preference classification and notes that a person using it may file as a self-petitioner.

Why it matters

Before 2016 the waiver was assessed under Matter of New York State Dep't of Transp. (NYSDOT), a 1998 decision. Dhanasar vacated it. The AAO explained that one NYSDOT term, "intrinsic," added little yet invited subjective judgment, and that "national in scope" was sometimes read too narrowly, as if only geographic reach counted. Anyone reading older material on the waiver needs to know that the test described there has been replaced.

The decision also fixes what must be shown and how strongly. The petitioner must demonstrate the three elements by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning it is more likely than not that each is met. If they are met, USCIS "may" approve the waiver as a matter of discretion. The waiver is described as purely discretionary, so the petitioner must also show that the person otherwise merits a favorable exercise of discretion.

How USCIS evaluates it

Qualifying for EB-2 comes first

The three elements are reached only after eligibility for EB-2 classification has been established. The decision points to 8 CFR 204.5(k) for the definitions used to decide whether someone is a member of the professions holding an advanced degree or has exceptional ability. It also repeats the statutory point that a degree or license does not by itself count as sufficient evidence of exceptional ability. A strong endeavor therefore cannot stand in for the underlying classification.

Substantial merit and national importance

The first element looks at the proposed endeavor, not at the person. The endeavor must have both substantial merit and national importance. The decision notes that some locally or regionally focused endeavors may still be of national importance even if their geographic scope is hard to quantify. For that reason the question is not answered by mapping where the work takes place.

Well positioned to advance the endeavor

The second element turns to the person. The petitioner must show that the foreign national is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor. The record therefore has to connect the person to the specific endeavor described, rather than only to the person's general field or credentials.

Balance in favor of waiving the requirements

The third element asks whether, on balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the job offer and, with it, the labor certification. The decision describes the labor certification process as a Department of Labor determination about the availability of U.S. workers and the effect on wages and working conditions. The balancing question concerns why that process should be set aside for this person.

Quantity, quality and discretion

The decision states that it considers both the quantity and the quality of evidence, including relevance, probative value and credibility. Even when the three elements are satisfied, approval remains a matter of discretion, so the final step is a review of whether the person merits a favorable exercise of it.

A practical example

This is an invented illustration. A researcher in aerospace engineering self-petitions for EB-2 with a national interest waiver. The file first shows an advanced degree, which addresses the underlying classification. It then describes one research endeavor in specific terms, explains why it matters beyond the researcher's own laboratory, documents the person's training and prior work on that topic, and sets out why waiving a job offer and labor certification would be beneficial. Each section is tied to one of the three elements, so a reader can follow from claim to exhibit.

A common misconception

One mistaken reading is that satisfying the three Dhanasar elements entitles the person to the waiver. The decision says instead that, once the elements are met, USCIS "may" approve the waiver as a matter of discretion, and that the petitioner must also show the person otherwise merits a favorable exercise of discretion.

Common problems

  • Skipping the EB-2 foundation

    A record can argue at length about national importance while leaving the advanced degree or exceptional ability question thinly documented. The decision treats EB-2 eligibility as a prior step, so a gap there leaves the three elements with nothing to rest on.

  • Describing a field instead of an endeavor

    The first element concerns the proposed endeavor. A narrative that praises an industry or a discipline in general terms, without saying what the person proposes to do, gives an officer no specific endeavor to assess for merit or importance.

  • Relying on the older NYSDOT wording

    Because Dhanasar vacated NYSDOT, a petition framed around "intrinsic" value or around geographic reach alone speaks to a test that no longer governs. The decision says national importance is not settled by geographic scope alone.

  • Leaving the balancing element unaddressed

    Some records establish the endeavor and the person's skills but say little about why waiving the job offer and labor certification would be beneficial. The third element asks for that reasoning directly, so its absence leaves part of the framework unanswered.

How to document it

  • Proof of the underlying EB-2 qualification

    Degree records or evidence of exceptional ability show the person meets the classification the decision requires before the waiver is considered.

  • A specific written description of the proposed endeavor

    A plain statement of what the person will do lets an officer judge merit and national importance on the endeavor itself.

  • Evidence of the endeavor's reach

    Independent materials about the problem the work addresses show why it matters, including for locally or regionally focused work.

  • Records of the person's relevant training and work

    Publications, project records and similar documents show how the person is positioned to advance this particular endeavor.

  • Documents that show concrete progress or plans

    Records of current work or next steps tie the person's position to the endeavor, not only to past credentials.

  • A section on the balance of benefits

    An explanation, with exhibits, of why waiving the job offer and labor certification would benefit the United States answers the third element.

  • A cover statement organized by element

    Headings for each element, each with exhibit references, let a reader trace every claim to its support.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Map your case on the Case Canvas

Last reviewed October 22, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.