Key takeaways
- Judging the work of others is discussed in 198 of the 326 decisions, the highest count in the index.
- Published material about the person is discussed in 191 decisions and prizes and awards in 174.
- Artistic exhibitions (37) and commercial success in the performing arts (12) have the lowest counts.
Petitioners often ask which EB-1A criteria the Administrative Appeals Office writes about most. This article answers that narrower question with a count. It describes what the 2026 decisions in Merito's index discuss. It does not describe how any of them came out.
Merito's index holds 326 AAO non-precedent decisions on EB-1A petitions from decision year 2026.
What the index counts
A decision is counted once for each criterion it discusses, and a decision usually discusses several. The counts therefore describe what the decisions discuss, not how they came out.
In practice, a criterion can show up in a decision for different reasons. The petitioner may have claimed it, an earlier officer may have addressed it, or the AAO may have explained its view of the submitted evidence. A count of discussion does not separate these cases, so read every figure below as a measure of attention in the text and nothing more.
A count of decisions that discuss a criterion is not an outcome rate. It says where the AAO wrote, not what it decided.
The most discussed criteria
Judging the work of others is discussed in 198 decisions. Published material about the person is discussed in 191 decisions. Prizes and awards is discussed in 174 decisions.
These three lead the list. For judging, that means keeping the invitations, the confirmations of completed reviews and the description of the venue together. For published material, it means keeping each item with its date, its publication details and a clear link to the person it covers. For awards, it means documenting the award itself, who granted it and on what basis.
The middle group
Original contributions is discussed in 170 decisions, a leading or critical role in 162, membership in associations in 153 and scholarly articles in 152.
What is useful is that each one has its own documentation pattern.
A role criterion usually calls for evidence that ties the person to the organization and shows what the role consisted of. A membership criterion calls for documents about the association itself, such as its requirements for joining. A scholarly articles criterion calls for the articles and information about where they appeared. An original contributions criterion calls for evidence connecting the work to its use or influence, not only a description of the work.
High salary is discussed in 118 decisions, which places it below that group. A salary claim is documented differently from the others, because it rests on pay records and a comparison set. Keep the pay documents and the comparison material in one place so a reader can follow the comparison without searching.
The least discussed criteria
Artistic exhibitions is discussed in 37 decisions, and commercial success in the performing arts in 12.
This article does not try to explain the lower counts. If either criterion applies to your work, the low count is no reason to leave it out, and it is no reason to include it either. Decide based on whether you can document it.
Using the data without over-reading it
The decisions come from the public repository that USCIS maintains. According to the USCIS page, you can search most non-precedent decisions dating back to 2005 in that repository. The page also states that decisions are typically posted within a month of the decision being rendered. It adds that USCIS redacts personally identifiable information and other sensitive material from non-precedent decisions before they are made public.
These details matter for how far a count can be pushed. A non-precedent decision is a statement about one record. A count across 326 of them tells you what topics recur in the writing, and it cannot tell you what a different record would show.
Compare your own exhibit list to that wording, not to a count.
Some practical ways to use the counts:
- Use the list to decide where to spend review time.
- For each criterion you claim, write a short statement that connects the documents to the regulatory wording, so a reader does not have to infer the link.
- Keep one exhibit set per criterion, labeled the same way in your index and your cover letter.
- Open a few decisions on a criterion you plan to claim and read how the AAO describes the documents it was given.
Sources
- USCIS: AAO Non-Precedent Decisions
- eCFR: 8 C.F.R. § 204.5
- Merito index: AAO non-precedent decisions on EB-1A petitions, decision year 2026 (n = 326)
How this was made: drafted with AI from the sources linked above, then every factual claim was checked against those sources by a separate review, and the links were checked on 2026-10-21. Merito is not a law firm and this is not legal advice.
Edited by Emilia Brown
Editor, Merito
Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.

