Skip to content
Merito
In this section

Non-Precedent Decision

EB-1AO-1AEB-2 NIWLaw and case law

5 min read

In short

A non-precedent decision is a ruling by the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) on one case that USCIS posts for the public but has not designated as a precedent. It explains how the AAO resolved that petitioner's record. Under 8 CFR 103.3(c), the binding effect on USCIS employees belongs to designated precedent decisions, not to every posted ruling.

Also known as: Unpublished AAO decision · AAO non-precedent decision · Non-precedent AAO ruling

Where it applies

  • In Merito's editorial classification, the term belongs to EB-1A, O-1A and EB-2 NIW. The USCIS repository sorts AAO non-precedent decisions by topic. Its listings include Form I-140 extraordinary ability decisions under section 203(b)(1)(A) of the INA and Form I-129 extraordinary ability (O) petitions.
  • The repository holds most non-precedent decisions dating back to 2005, and USCIS says they are typically posted within a month of the decision. The regulation says an officer who denies a petition must explain the specific reasons in writing, and that certain unfavorable decisions may be appealed. An appeal decision must also be in writing.

Why it matters

Reading a non-precedent decision shows how the AAO described and weighed one record. It does not state a rule for other cases. A precedent such as Matter of Dhanasar, published as 26 I&N Dec. 884, announces a framework for national interest waivers and vacates an earlier one. A posted non-precedent ruling announces nothing comparable.

The burden of proof stays on the person seeking the benefit, and the usual standard is preponderance of the evidence. A decision about someone else's documents cannot supply facts about the reader's own. It can show what kind of gap the AAO saw in a record, which helps a reader check whether the same gap appears in theirs.

How USCIS evaluates it

Binding force

The regulation at 8 CFR 103.3(c) provides that designated decisions published as precedent serve as precedents in all proceedings involving the same issues, and bind all Service employees unless later modified or overruled. The regulation gives that effect to designated decisions. A decision posted in the repository without that designation is not described there as binding.

Same issue, different record

Even a precedent applies to proceedings involving the same issue. A non-precedent decision rests on its own facts: the exhibits, letters and dates that one petitioner filed. Any comparison depends on how closely the records match. A shared label, such as the same criterion or the same form, does not make two records alike.

Redacted and searchable

USCIS removes personally identifiable information and other sensitive material before posting, and the first page carries a notation such as "(b)(6)". Readers can search by form number, subject, regulation, or any text in the decision, or by the unique case identification number. These features make decisions findable, but they do not add authority.

Stated reasons on appeal

The regulation requires an appeal to identify specifically any erroneous conclusion of law or statement of fact, and an appeal that does not may be summarily dismissed. The appeal is filed on Form I-290B within 30 days after service of the decision. A reader of a non-precedent decision can follow how the AAO answered the specific points raised.

A practical example

This is an invented illustration. A researcher reads a posted AAO decision in which an appeal was dismissed because a reviewer letter did not say which journals were involved or how many manuscripts were judged. The researcher does not treat it as a rule. Instead, the researcher checks the invitations and letters in their own file to see whether they name the journals, the dates and the work reviewed. The record then answers the question the other decision left open.

A common misconception

One mistaken reading is that a posted AAO decision binds USCIS the way a precedent does. The regulation at 8 CFR 103.3(c) gives binding effect to decisions designated as precedent. The repository holds non-precedent decisions, posted with personal information redacted.

Common problems

  • Quoting a ruling as if it were a rule

    A cover letter that presents a non-precedent holding as settled law asks the officer to treat it as something the regulation does not describe it as. The regulation gives binding effect to designated precedents, so a bare quotation does little work.

  • Matching on labels instead of facts

    A decision may involve the same criterion or the same form as the reader's petition and still turn on a different record. Without a comparison of what each file contained, the cited decision shows little about the reader's file.

  • Incomplete citations

    A reference that omits the decision date, form type or case identification number leaves the reader unable to locate it. The repository supports searching by case number, so including it makes the decision easy to find.

  • Borrowing evidence the file lacks

    Describing what another petitioner submitted does not place any of it in the reader's record. Because the burden of proof rests on the person seeking the benefit, the supporting documents must be in the petition itself.

How to document it

  • Full citation details

    Record the decision date, the form type and the unique case number so anyone can retrieve the same decision from the repository.

  • A short fact comparison

    A table that sets the other record's key facts beside your own shows an officer exactly where the two records match and where they differ.

  • Your own exhibits for every point

    Each proposition should rest on documents in your file, such as contracts, letters or published items, rather than on another decision's description of someone else's.

  • Precedent versus non-precedent labels

    Mark which cited decisions are designated precedents, such as Dhanasar, and which are non-precedent, so the reader can see the difference in their status.

  • Letters naming sources

    A letter that identifies the specific work, dates and where the claim can be checked gives an officer something concrete to verify.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Search AAO decisions in the Explorer

Last reviewed October 23, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.