Skip to content
Merito
In this section

Prospective Impact

EB-2 NIWEB-2 NIW

5 min read

In short

Prospective impact is the forward-looking effect that a proposed endeavor could have, as opposed to what the person has already done. In an EB-2 national interest waiver (NIW) case, the Matter of Dhanasar decision tells officers to consider an endeavor's potential prospective impact when deciding whether it has national importance. It is a judgment about future reach and significance, not a promise of results.

Also known as: Future impact · Potential impact of the endeavor · Forward-looking benefit

Where it applies

  • The term belongs to the EB-2 NIW category. A person first has to fit the underlying second-preference classification, which the statute describes as a member of the professions holding an advanced degree or a person of exceptional ability. The national interest waiver then lets the Secretary of Homeland Security set aside the requirement that an employer in the United States seek the person's services.
  • Within the waiver analysis, prospective impact sits in the first prong of the Dhanasar framework: whether the proposed endeavor has substantial merit and national importance. In the decision, the AAO says that in judging national importance it considers the endeavor's potential prospective impact. The idea therefore concerns the endeavor itself, not the person's qualifications, which the second prong addresses.

Why it matters

National importance is one of the two elements of the first prong, and an endeavor that does not meet it ends the analysis there. Dhanasar shows this in practice: the petitioner's proposed STEM teaching was found to have substantial merit, but the record did not show by a preponderance of the evidence that he would affect STEM education more broadly. The AAO therefore did not reach the remaining prongs for that teaching.

The point is that a worthwhile activity is not the same as one with broad implications. A petition that describes only the work performed day to day leaves an officer with little to weigh about what the work could change beyond the immediate setting. A petition that explains who or what the work could reach, and supports that explanation with evidence, gives the officer something to assess.

How USCIS evaluates it

Potential, read from the endeavor

Dhanasar frames the question around the endeavor's potential. The AAO describes national importance as something that may arise, for example, because an undertaking has national or even global implications within a particular field, such as those from certain improved manufacturing processes or medical advances. The officer is reading what the endeavor could bring about if carried out, so the description of the endeavor needs to be specific enough to support that reading.

Broader implications, not geography alone

The decision states that prospective impact is not evaluated solely in geographic terms. Instead, the AAO looks for broader implications. It adds that ventures and undertakings focused on one geographic area of the United States may properly be considered to have national importance. A regional project can be read in light of what it implies for a field or for the country, and a nationwide location does not by itself settle the question.

Economic impact is helpful but not required

According to Dhanasar, evidence that an endeavor has the potential for significant economic impact may be favorable, but it is not required. Merit may be established without immediate or quantifiable economic impact. The decision gives research, pure science and the furtherance of human knowledge as examples that may qualify whether or not the results are likely to translate into economic benefits for the United States. The Policy Manual separately lists potential economic impact and potential job creation as more specific considerations in the third prong.

A practical example

This is an invented illustration. A materials scientist proposes to develop a lower-cost coating process for industrial equipment. One description says only that the scientist will keep running tests at a university lab. A fuller description explains which industries use such equipment, what the process could change for them, and which independent specialists have commented on the method. The second version gives an officer a basis to consider broader implications in the field, while the first describes activity without saying what it could affect.

A common misconception

One mistaken reading is that prospective impact must be shown as a measurable economic figure or a nationwide footprint. Dhanasar says economic impact may be favorable but is not required, and that prospective impact is not evaluated solely in geographic terms, so a locally focused endeavor can still be found nationally important.

Common problems

  • Merit described, importance left unexplained

    A record may show that the work is useful or admirable yet say nothing about how it reaches beyond the immediate setting. The STEM teaching example in Dhanasar shows the gap: substantial merit was recognized, but the record did not show an effect on the field more broadly. A reader can see this gap when every sentence describes activity and none describes consequence.

  • Impact framed only by location

    A petition that argues importance purely by pointing to where the work happens, or how many places it touches, leaves out the broader implications the AAO says it looks for. The decision rejects reading the concept solely in geographic terms, so a map of sites does not explain what the work means for a field.

  • Plans with no independent backing

    The Policy Manual notes that business plans and similar descriptions should be supported by other independent evidence. A plan whose projections cite no outside source leaves an officer nothing to check. The weakness is visible as a gap between a confident description and the documents attached to it.

How to document it

  • A specific endeavor statement

    A clear description of what the person will do, for whom, and what it could change. It lets an officer connect the proposed work to the broader implications the decision describes.

  • Independent expert letters

    Letters from field experts with first-hand knowledge that give specific examples and rest on other independent evidence, as the Policy Manual describes.

  • Field-level sources

    Reports, government or industry documents, or published studies showing the problem the endeavor addresses and who is affected, which place the work in a wider context.

  • Plans with supporting records

    A business plan or project plan paired with independent records, such as agreements, funding documents or user interest, since plans alone are meant to be supported.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Plan your expert letters

Last reviewed October 22, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.