In short
Regulatory criteria are the ten types of evidence listed in the extraordinary ability regulation, 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(i) through (x). A petitioner who does not show a one-time major, internationally recognized award must submit evidence that meets at least three of them. Each criterion has its own wording, and a document counts toward a criterion only if it fits that wording.
Also known as: Evidentiary criteria · Threshold criteria · The ten criteria

Where it applies
- The term belongs to the EB-1A category, the classification for people of extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business or athletics. The statute describes that classification in 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(1)(A). The regulation that lists the criteria is 8 CFR 204.5(h), and the petition is filed on Form I-140. The regulation says the petition must come with evidence of sustained national or international acclaim and of recognition of the person's achievements in the field.
- That evidence must include either a one-time achievement, described as a major, internationally recognized award, or at least three of the ten listed types. The list covers lesser prizes, selective memberships, published material about the person, judging the work of others, original contributions of major significance, scholarly articles, displays at exhibitions, leading or critical roles, high remuneration and commercial success in the performing arts.
- The USCIS Policy Manual places the criteria in the first part of a two-step review. The Ninth Circuit's decision in Kazarian v. USCIS addresses how the criteria are to be counted. The regulation also allows comparable evidence when the listed standards do not readily apply to the person's occupation, so the ten types are the main route and not the only one.
Why it matters
The criteria give the petition its basic structure. Because the regulation sets a minimum of three types of evidence, a petition that falls short of that count has not cleared the first step. Kazarian shows how this plays out: the court said that whether an applicant presents two types of evidence or none, the proper procedure is to count the types provided, and an applicant who does not reach three has not met the requirement.
The criteria also set limits on what an officer may demand. In Kazarian, the court found that the AAO erred when it required peer citations for scholarly articles and required external dissertation review for judging, because those requirements were not in the regulation. The court said such points might matter later, in the final merits determination, but not in the question of whether three types of evidence were provided. Knowing the exact wording of each criterion therefore tells a reader what the criterion asks and what it does not.
Meeting the criteria is not the end of the review. The Policy Manual says the evidence must ultimately establish that the person is one of that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field. It also notes that voluminous documentation may not contain enough persuasive evidence to establish eligibility.
How USCIS evaluates it
Step one asks whether a criterion is met
The Policy Manual describes a two-step review. In the first, the officer decides, by a preponderance of the evidence, which submitted evidence objectively meets the parameters of the regulatory description for its type. That is the sense in which the manual uses the phrase regulatory criteria. The step is limited: officers are told not to decide yet whether the person has sustained acclaim or belongs to the small percentage at the top of the field.
Quality can matter inside a criterion
The manual says officers consider the quality and caliber of evidence in step one to the extent a criterion has qualitative requirements. For the awards criterion, relevant considerations include the criteria used to grant the award, its national or international significance in the field, the number of recipients and any limits on competitors. The manual contrasts an award open only within one locality, employer or school, which may have little recognition, with an award from a well-known national institution or professional organization.
Focus on the person, not the employer
The manual states that the description of the awards criterion focuses on the person's receipt of the award and not on the employer's receipt. It adds that a team award can be relied on if the person is one of its recipients. Reading the wording closely in this way shows why a document about an organization's achievement may not, by itself, fit a criterion written about an individual.
Wording and the number of exhibits
The manual says the evidence need not use the word extraordinary, but the material should make it readily apparent that the person's contributions are qualifying. It also says that although the regulation sometimes uses plurals, a single piece of evidence in a category may be sufficient. The same passage cautions that a large volume of documents does not on its own establish eligibility.
Comparable evidence
When the listed standards do not readily apply to the person's occupation, the regulation permits comparable evidence. The manual says a general unsupported assertion that a criterion does not apply is not probative, while a detailed, specific and credible statement from the petitioner can be enough. It also says there is no comparable evidence for the one-time achievement of a major, internationally recognized award.
A practical example
This is an invented illustration. A software engineer's record contains a national industry award given to individual developers, a feature article about her work in a major trade publication, and invitations to review submissions for a professional conference. Reading the regulation, an officer can ask whether the award went to her personally, whether the article shows its title, date and author as the published material criterion describes, and whether the reviewing fits the judging criterion. If each document fits its criterion, three types are present. The question of whether the whole record shows a place at the top of the field is then a separate matter, handled in the final merits determination.
A common misconception
One mistaken reading is that meeting three regulatory criteria settles the petition. The sources say instead that the three-criteria count is the first step, and that the officer must then consider the evidence as a whole to decide whether the person is one of that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field.
Common problems
Evidence that does not match the criterion's wording
Each criterion describes a specific kind of evidence. In Kazarian, the court upheld the AAO's view that a self-published textbook, community college lectures and conference presentations were not displays at artistic exhibitions or showcases, and that letters from physics professors did not show contributions that were major. A document may be genuine and still not be the type the criterion names, which leaves the officer with nothing to count for that criterion.
Counting on an award that is limited in reach
The manual says an award available only within a single locality, employer or school may have little national or international recognition. A record that presents such an award without showing who is eligible, how winners are chosen and how many receive it leaves a gap an officer can see when weighing the qualitative requirements of the criterion.
Treating the employer's recognition as the person's
The awards criterion is described in terms of the person's own receipt. Material showing that a company or team won something, without showing that the person was a recipient, does not speak to the wording the manual describes.
How to document it
A criterion-by-criterion map
List each criterion relied on next to the exhibits meant to satisfy it, using the regulation's own words. This lets an officer see how each document fits its criterion.
Proof of the person's own role
For awards, show that the person is a named recipient, including on a team award. This addresses the manual's focus on the person's receipt.
Rules and selection details for each award
Criteria for granting it, who may compete, how many receive it and its national or international standing. These are the considerations the manual lists.
Published material with its identifying details
The regulation says published material should include the title, date and author and any necessary translation. Including them, with the publication's standing, makes the document easier to check.
Evidence of what was judged or contributed
For judging or contributions, documents that show the actual activity and its significance, since Kazarian upheld a finding that contributions were not shown to be major.
A detailed statement for comparable evidence
If a criterion does not readily apply, a specific and credible explanation of why, with evidence of comparable significance, is what the manual says can be sufficient.
Official sources
- 8 CFR 204.5 (petitions for employment-based immigrants) — accessed October 22, 2026
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 (Extraordinary Ability) — accessed October 22, 2026
- Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010) — accessed October 22, 2026
- 8 U.S.C. 1153 (INA 203, allocation of immigrant visas) — accessed October 22, 2026
Use it in Merito
Build your evidence checklistLast reviewed October 22, 2026
