Skip to content
Merito
In this section

Matter of Ho (reliability of the record)

EB-1AO-1AEB-2 NIWLaw and case law

5 min read

In short

Matter of Ho is a case name that Merito uses as a label for one question: how far the documents in a petition can be trusted as a record. The source texts for this entry do not reproduce that decision, so the entry does not state what it held. It explains, from the USCIS Policy Manual, a precedent decision and a court opinion, how relevance, probative value and credibility enter an officer's reading of evidence.

Also known as: reliability of the record · reliable evidence

Where it applies

  • Merito classes this term under EB-1A, O-1A and EB-2 NIW. The idea behind it is not tied to one category. The Policy Manual says that most administrative immigration proceedings use the preponderance of the evidence standard, and that relevant, probative and credible evidence is what can satisfy it. Matter of Dhanasar, which concerns the national interest waiver in EB-2, says the same standard applies there and that the quality of evidence counts alongside its quantity.
  • Kazarian v. USCIS shows the same concern in an extraordinary ability petition. The court described letters and a self-published textbook that an officer was asked to weigh. The sources given here do not reproduce Matter of Ho itself, so this entry makes no claim about what that decision says, how it is cited or at which stage of a case it is used.

Why it matters

The Policy Manual states that the burden of proof falls solely on the person asking for the benefit and never shifts to USCIS. A record that an officer cannot rely on is therefore the petitioner's problem to solve. If the standard is not met, the manual says it is appropriate for the officer to request more evidence, issue a notice of intent to deny, or deny the case.

The reliability of the record also shapes what happens after a denial. The regulation at 8 CFR 103.3 requires an officer who denies a petition to explain the specific reasons in writing. It also says an appeal is summarily dismissed when the party fails to identify specifically any erroneous conclusion of law or statement of fact. A reader who understands which documents an officer found unreliable can see what an appeal would have to address.

How USCIS evaluates it

Relevant, probative and credible

The Policy Manual describes the evidence that can meet the standard as relevant, probative and credible. Relevant means the document bears on an element that must be shown. Probative means it actually helps prove that element. Credible means it can be believed. A document can fail on any one of these three. A real certificate about an unrelated matter is relevant to nothing, and a vague statement can be believable yet prove very little.

Quality as well as quantity

Dhanasar says that, under the preponderance standard, the AAO considers not only the quantity but also the quality of the evidence, including relevance, probative value and credibility. Piling up exhibits therefore does not settle the matter by itself. An officer can ask what each exhibit establishes and whether it can be relied on, and a small set of strong documents may say more than a large set of weak ones.

Statements that name no support

Kazarian offers a concrete picture. A colleague wrote that a self-published textbook was certain to be required reading in many schools, yet the court noted that the petitioner presented no evidence that the book was used in any class. A claim about the future or about wide use, with no document behind it, gives an officer nothing to check against the record.

A practical example

This is an invented illustration. A researcher states in a personal declaration that a software tool she built is used by many laboratories. Two supporting letters repeat the same claim without naming a laboratory. A third letter, from a lab director, names her lab, describes how the tool is used in its pipeline and attaches a dated internal report. An officer reading the file can check the third letter against the report, while the first two give nothing to check. The petition would be easier to follow if each broad statement pointed to a document, such as a user list or a download record, that shows the same fact independently.

A common misconception

One mistaken reading is that a long list of exhibits settles the question of reliability. The sources say instead that the quality of evidence, including its relevance, probative value and credibility, is considered alongside its quantity, and that the burden of proof stays with the petitioner.

Common problems

  • Claims without a checkable source

    A letter may say that work is widely used or important without saying who uses it, where or since when. In Kazarian, a colleague's prediction about a textbook was accompanied by no evidence of actual classroom use. A reader can see that gap, and it limits what the statement can prove.

  • Exhibits that do not match the claim

    A document may be genuine yet relate to something other than the element it is offered for. Because the Policy Manual speaks of relevant and probative evidence, an exhibit that does not bear on the stated element adds length without adding proof.

  • Details that differ between documents

    If a role, date or title is described one way in a letter and another way in a contract, a reader has to decide which version to believe. That uncertainty touches credibility. The sources do not say how an officer resolves such a conflict, so this entry does not either.

How to document it

  • Primary documents behind each claim

    Contracts, certificates, publications and records created at the time of the event show the fact directly, so a reader need not rely on someone's later description of it.

  • Letters that name their sources

    A letter that says how the writer knows the work and points to specific documents gives an officer something to verify.

  • An exhibit index tied to each element

    A table that pairs every exhibit with the element it supports shows its relevance on the page.

  • A consistency check across the file

    Comparing titles, dates, employers and roles in the CV, letters and contracts lets a reader see whether the documents agree before an officer does.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Organize your exhibits in the Evidence Binder

Last reviewed October 23, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.