In short
Matter of Caron International is the name of a decision filed here under the weight given to expert opinion, meaning how far an officer relies on an outside expert's statement. The supplied sources do not reproduce the decision, so this entry does not state its holding. It explains how expert letters are read as evidence, using the Policy Manual, Kazarian and Dhanasar.
Also known as: Caron International · weight of expert opinion · expert opinion letters

Where it applies
- Merito files this term under EB-1A, O-1A and EB-2 NIW. It concerns written statements from outside experts who comment on a person's work or field. The name points to a decision called Matter of Caron International, but the source texts supplied for this entry do not reproduce it, so the entry does not say what the decision holds. It describes instead how the Policy Manual, Kazarian and Dhanasar treat evidence.
- Two of those sources show expert letters inside actual records. In Kazarian, an extraordinary-ability petition on Form I-140 carried reference letters, including one from a physics professor; USCIS denied it, the AAO dismissed the appeal, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed. In Dhanasar, a national interest waiver petitioner submitted expert letters on hypersonic propulsion research, and the AAO sustained the appeal on de novo review. The sources do not say the letters alone decided either result.
Why it matters
The burden of proof falls solely on the person requesting the benefit and never shifts to USCIS. An expert letter is one way to carry that burden, but it remains evidence. Under the preponderance standard, relevant, probative and credible evidence must lead the officer to believe a claim is probably true. A letter that states a conclusion alone asks the officer to accept the author's word; a letter tied to documents lets the officer see its basis.
Dhanasar adds that the AAO considers the quality of evidence, including relevance, probative value and credibility, and not only its quantity. The count of letters is therefore not the measure. What turns on each letter is who wrote it, what it describes, and whether the rest of the record bears it out. The weight given to a statement depends on how the whole record reads.
How USCIS evaluates it
Quality of the evidence
Dhanasar, citing Matter of Chawathe, says both quantity and quality count, and it names relevance, probative value and credibility. For a letter, relevance asks whether it addresses a point actually at issue. Probative value asks whether it shows something. Credibility asks whether the statement can be believed. A letter that names its basis gives an officer something to test.
Detail and corroboration
In Dhanasar the AAO described letters that explained the research in detail and came from individuals who established their own expertise. They sat beside media articles, government funding and documented project roles. The decision treats the significance of the research as corroborated by that other evidence, so the letters were read together with it and not in isolation.
Praise measured against the regulation
In Kazarian, letters called the petitioner diligent, and one said his research matched the caliber expected of a young professor at a strong university. The AAO still found that none of the regulatory criteria was satisfied, and the court affirmed. The regulation asks USCIS to decide whether the evidence shows sustained acclaim and a place at the very top of the field, so favorable words are measured against that wording.
The unmet standard
The Policy Manual says that when a requestor has not met the standard, an officer may request additional evidence, issue a notice of intent to deny, or deny the case. A letter that leaves a gap in the record is read within that frame: it is part of what the requestor offers, and the officer decides whether the whole offering suffices.
A practical example
Invented illustration: a petitioner submits two letters. One, from a former supervisor, says the person is among the best in the field and gives no project, date or source. The other names a specific project, explains what the person built, and attaches the published paper and the funding award that the letter mentions. An officer reading the first letter has nothing to check beyond the author's word. An officer reading the second can compare each statement with the attached documents.
A common misconception
One mistaken reading is that a letter from a distinguished expert settles the point it addresses. The sources instead treat letters as evidence: the burden stays on the petitioner, and the officer considers relevance, probative value and credibility along with the rest of the record.
Common problems
Praise without a stated basis
In Kazarian, a colleague wrote that the petitioner's textbook was certain to be required reading in many schools, yet the opinion notes that no evidence showed it was used in any class. A prediction or compliment with no source leaves an officer nothing to check.
The author's expertise is not shown
The Dhanasar letters came from individuals who established their own expertise. A letter that omits the author's background or relationship to the work leaves the reader unable to see why the opinion deserves attention.
Letters standing alone
When the only support for a claim is letters repeating it, the record offers no independent check. In Dhanasar the significance of the research was corroborated by peer interest and repeated government funding, evidence that does not depend on anyone's say-so.
How to document it
The author's background
A short biography or CV in or with each letter shows what qualifies the author to comment.
The documents a letter cites
Attaching the paper, contract, award or project record lets the officer compare each statement with its source.
Independent corroboration
Funding records, media coverage or evidence of others citing the work show the claim does not rest on the letter alone.
A statement of what each letter addresses
Pairing each letter with the specific element or criterion it supports keeps its relevance visible.
Consistent facts across the record
Titles, dates and role descriptions that match across letters, CV and exhibits support credibility.
Official sources
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 1, Part E, Chapter 4 (Burden and Standards of Proof) — accessed October 23, 2026
- Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010) — accessed October 23, 2026
- Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016) — accessed October 23, 2026
Use it in Merito
Plan your expert lettersLast reviewed October 23, 2026
